Wednesday, May 05, 2010

Why do we call it sexual misconduct?

It’s rape.

A south Georgia priest belonging to the Glenmary religious order is awaiting trial involving allegations of sexual misconduct with a 10-year-old boy in West Virginia.

RopertPoandi A priest raped a child. The headline sounds gruesome, right? Perhaps the press prefers a headline that is less graphic? Or perhaps they want to construct and image that does not bring to mind the base violation of a child? I don’t know the answer, but I want to know.

Rev. Bob Poandl is the priest in this case. There a few details on his alleged crime besides the words “sexual misconduct.”

The Rev. Bob Poandl was indicted by a West Virginia grand jury in January on charges that he engaged in sexual misconduct with a child in the early 1990s in Roane County, W.Va.

Looking a little deeper I found that Rev. Poandl was charged with first-degree sexual abuse, first-degree sexual assault, and sexual abuse by a custodian.

The offender engages in sexual intercourse or sexual intrusion without the consent of the victim and during the attack inflicts serious bodily injury or uses a deadly weapon. The offender is 14 years old or more and engages in sexual intercourse or sexual intrusion with another person who is 11 years old or less.

Rape. A Catholic priest allegedly raped a child. The headline should read Rev. Bob Poandl arrested for child rape.

I’m tired of pulling punches.

Comments (21)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I agree with you completely. It is a major trick of the religious world, changing the names of things so they don't sound so awful.
Polygamy is my recent favorite, a very lovely word that masks and hides rape, pedophilia and adultery. I'm also rather fond of sacrifice, which is a very nice word to describe murder.
2 replies · active 779 weeks ago
ThatAtheistChick's avatar

ThatAtheistChick · 779 weeks ago

That smug looking bastard looks like a child molester.
He is a good and well loved priest who has now been cleared.
Are they trying to downplay the event because he is a priest or do they do this with all people who are charged with these types of crimes? I figure some would say they are doing this to protect the child but that only works if they do it for all charged. I figure the more religious the writer of the story the more they try to play it down when they publish the story.
The way i was raised, age 12 = adult. Sinner boy!
You will, I know, be delighted to hear that Father Bob Poandl has been cleared and the Judge branded his accuser, a liar (I wonder why, wouldn't have anything to do with a massive payout would it?)
Maryborden's avatar

Maryborden · 762 weeks ago

Just for the record, though I wonder if it is worth saying, there are sometimes innocent people in this world who are falsely accused. This was the case with Father Poandl, a good and holy priest. A careful reading of the link to the story, which includes statements by Father's defense team, indicate the tip of the iceberg of why the judge dismissed the charges "with prejudice" - the accuser was found by the court to be lying, and the case was dismissed - not on a technicality, but because the prosection no longer had a believable witness. Whether the rest of the iceberg will ever be seen or not, and accepted for what it is or not, no one is benefitted by false accusation, including other victims who deserve to be heard.
Maryborden's avatar

Maryborden · 762 weeks ago

Here is the link directly to the Judge's ruling - it is his actual document in the usual ".pdf" format, and is linked to the Glenmary website, www.glenmary.org - so if this link doesn't work for some reason, you can see the "court order" line on the right side of their Home page. I'll come around again to see what you think, when you've read it, and since you are familiar with legal terminology, I think it will add up to what we "laymen" call "lying". Thanks for allowing me to enter into the disucssion. Maryborden
http://www.glenmary.org/Whats_new/2010/August/Cou...
4 replies · active 762 weeks ago
Thanks for the links Maryborden.
Thanks for the links Maryborden.
Maryborden's avatar

Maryborden · 762 weeks ago

All in the interest of justice - here is another link I just noticed, wtih a further report on some of the "hidden iceberg". My prayers are with all who seek the truth.
http://www.thetimesrecord.net/front1.shtml
Thanks for the links Maryborden.
Maryborden's avatar

Maryborden · 762 weeks ago

Oh, by the way, I want to thank Mojoey for detailing in his post what the charges of first-degree sexual abuse and first-degree sexual assault actually mean - that "the offender . . . during the attack inflicts serious bodily injury or uses a deadly weapon." That clarfies why the Judge took pains to point out in #13, that in the incident of the "severely broken right arm" in 1991 for which "the accuser received treatment", just a few weeks after the alleged incident, there were no medical records furnished which might reveal a physical examination which could confirm or deny whether he, as a 10 year old child, would have suffered injuries, if he was abused, as he has alleged", and that (in #19) "It is imperative that medical records be secured, to see what evidence there is."
For those who browse this site, here are a couple new links Maryborden hasn't posted - Father Poandl was restored to active ministry today, and also the Diocese of Tyler, TX, states that after his having worked there for 6 years in the 1990's, no one has come forward with any accusations. This has also been confirmed by Glenmary, whose President reports that Father has never had any other accusation brought against him in over 40 years of priestly ministry. The links are:
http://www.glenmary.org/Whats_new/2010/August/Poa...
http://www.dioceseoftyler.org/documents/Statement...

Post a new comment

Comments by