Monday, February 01, 2010

Baptists with good intentions

I saw the story about Baptists kidnapping Haitian children over the weekend. The headline seemed odd given what I knew of the situation in Haiti. Apparently, a Baptist group gathered up orphans tried to relocate them to a orphanage in Dominican Republic. In the process, they were arrested for kidnapping. I thought the story sounded like a mistake. I waited before deciding to post. The more I waited, the more it looked like a clown circus, a Baptist clown circus.  These people should not be shocked their arrest. They caused their own problem. It is possible they had good intentions, but their execution was horrible.

While I was in China, the coverage of the earthquake in Haiti was the lead story every hour. It was overwhelming. One story sticks out. A truckload of babies was shown by the BBC. They had nobody to care for them. No baby formula. No diapers. Hell, no mothers, fathers, aunts, or uncles either. They were orphaned with few prospects and sick. The reporter asked, “What are we to do?” The Baptists responded to the call for help. I believe they wanted to help. We must remember this when writing about how poorly they executed their mission.

The Haitian government wants us to believe that criminals are stealing babies for use in the sex trade or for illegal adoption. However, they offer no proof and the media allows them to keep making the assertion as if were fact. At the same time, the Haitian government is doing to little to help the orphans. They have bigger issues and limited capabilities.

The Baptists…. they are well meaning idiots. Only the most incompetent and self-deluded people would think they could pick up a bunch of kids and transport them to a better place across an international border. From what I’ve read, they did not even vet the children to see if they were economic orphans, earthquake orphans, or real orphans in need of a home. No… they mixed their mission. Instead of helping children in need, they instead saw an opportunity to save kids for Christ. It is the same kind of corrupt thinking that causes Christians to think abstinence only education is the answer to teen pregnancy.

Now I see they are resting comfortably in custody waiting for their day in court. Good for them. They need a wakeup call.

U.S. embassy officials visited the Americans over the weekend at a jail near the airport in Port-au-Prince, where they are being detained. They are being treated well and are holding on to their faith, the Americans said

…"God is our provider and God gives us strength and comfort," said Carla Thompson, one group member. "We have our Bibles and we are OK."

Is their faith really being tested here? No…

As time passes, the story gets more confusing. Especially when we find out that they did little to find the parents of the children they were tying to help.

"Some of them for sure are not orphans," he told CNN. "Immediately after she arrived here, a girl -- she might be 9 years old -- was crying loudly, 'I am not an orphan, I do have my parents, please call my parents,' " he said.

The cynical voice inside my head keeps telling me to question the Baptist’s story. Were they really trying to help? Or did they see this as an opportunity they could not pass up? I really want to believe the former but I think we will find out the latter is true.

Technorati Tags: ,,

Comments (473)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I hope they were well intentioned. I cannot believe they were stupid enough to think they could pull this off....just go in and round up some orphans for the orphanage they plan to build in DR. Opportunistic. Sadly, sadly opportunistic -- let's take advantage of this catastrophe to kick-start our orphanage population.

I hope their hearts were in the right place, but really.....this is just nuts.

Clearly, the fact I am stunned by this shows I've not been reading your blog long enough.....
I am still at a lose in understand what they were thinking. I can understand the youngest thinking that what they were doing was ok simply because those with her said it was. I am afraid they really are as arrogant in their beliefs as the media has been hinting at. They really believe that their god had ordered this and that the devil has interfered.

I have been reading some of the news this morning and now there is a chance they will be tried here in the USA. I think this is a mistake because to many will allow the so called good intentions to hold to much sway in deciding their guilt or innocence. If they had set up a small tent city in Haiti and provided the kids with their needs and checked to insure that all the kids were orphans I could agree that their intentions were good but they just seemed to come in and grab a bunch of kids with no intentions of insuring that they were anything more then objects to be manipulated.
I'm a little more skeptical still, though I'm not ready to say they were certainly intending to do wrong. I don't understand why, if their main objective was to help these kids, were the kids hungry and dehydrated when the van was pulled over? Was everyone in that state and the news simply failed to report it? How could a group of people so seemingly dedicated to help allow a 3 month old to become so dehydrated he had to be hospitalized when authorities stopped them?

Why did they hand out pamphlets to people, encouraging them to give their kids over for a better life? Why are there parents coming forward and claiming that they were told their child would be sent to a boarding school, not that they were giving their child up for the possibility of adoption?

I want to believe these are short-sighted but helpful people who did something incredibly stupid but the more I hear about the incident, the less faith I have in their good intentions.
455 replies · active 793 weeks ago
They had no good intentions for the children. They only care about what they think their god wants them to do. The children are a side issue, their real intent was to do something that would please their god, thereby making them think they might have a chance of getting into heaven. Sane people would be more careful and treat the children with respect, not use them in some religous feel good sharade.
Watch the Today show, they had the minister from the church and the head of the orpahanage. Some people my be nieve in thinking that they are doing something right, but you do not have to to cut them, down by calling them stupid. What have you done to help the people in Haiti.
2 replies · active 793 weeks ago
I am sure the truth is somewhere in the middle as usually is when the media gets involved in situations like this. However, I don't think it is just naivety at work. There is a genuine level of stupidity going on if you think you can take any child (or person) across international borders with out proper paperwork.
I agree with everyone that "hopes" that they had good intentions. The situation is messed up and perhaps they thought the fastest/best way to help was to NOT go through the proper channels-after all there were no channels. Still, we all have to play by the rules, which is not a xtian strong point. They can defy science (resurrection), believe in miracles (logic, critical thinking) and arrogantly did what they wanted (freedom) in that situation. Still, we are all apologetic in that we hope that they had the best intentions.

Hope your China trip was awesome, welcome back.

Kriss
Jebus, Mojoey, your last was re-posted 544 times.

That’s weird?
1 reply · active 793 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by