Thursday, August 21, 2008

Pondering Clergy Sexual Abuse

The investigation into the background and possible additional crimes of former Youth pastor Joshua Ponder spread to his former church. Prior to his arrest for the sexual assault of a teenager, Ponder was a youth pastor at the First Baptist Church of Palestine from June 2001 to May 2007.

The Rev. Jay Abernathy, pastor of First Baptist Church of Palestine, was notified of Ponder’s arrest late last week and said the church would cooperate with police in the investigation, if asked.

“We are shocked and saddened by this incident, and are praying for everyone involved,” Abernathy said Monday afternoon. “We have made counselors available to our youth and families who may be hurting and will be available to anyone in our church and community who wants to talk.

“We are working to respond to everyone hurt by this.”

The police will talk to every young person Ponder came into contact with while a youth pastor in Palestine. The conversations will be intrusive and embarrassing. This is how atheists are born.  For atheist born of pastoral misconduct, it comes with a profound loss of faith when one learns that a person they trusted with their closest secrets are capable of apocryphal leadership and morally corrupt levels of sexual violence. Joshua Ponder's crime will touch dozens of young lives. Are there really people out there in Texas who think the small good Ponder accomplished as a youth pastor offset this level of violence and intrusion?

Related post: Baptist youth pastor arrested on sex charges

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
A former student's avatar

A former student · 868 weeks ago

You do not personally know Josh so you should reallly not be saying ANYTHING until you know him and the whole situations. I have know Ponder for a long time and it is only through him that I, and many others from his former youth groups, or Christians here today. What more can someone do then to help someone be saved? How many people has this man led to Christ? How many have you? The bible says that only GOD sees the hearts of men, and "judge not lest you be judged" so all i have to say is watch what you say when you don't know what you're talking about. The devil is a powerful thing but God is more powerful and can correct ANY wrong! Is this worse then killing someone? NO!! And look and David, He killed a man had an affair with his wife and God still loved him and says he was one of the greatest kings in all of history and "a man after (gods) own heart" Thing about what you say before you say it!
2 replies · active 867 weeks ago
1. Ponder's crime is public record. I do not need to know him to comment on his actions.
2. Being a Christian is not something I respect on face value. People can do much more than bring people to Christ. Take learning think critically for instance.
3. I do not recognize the bible as an authority on what I can do. We live in a secular country where I have the right to form my own judgments. I don't worry about being judged. If I've done something wrong, I deserve it.
4. I don't believe in the devil either.
5. What do I care about a fictional bible character. I care about what Ponder did. You should too.
6. It does not matter if murder is worse the sexual abuse. It's wrong on a fundamental level. It's even worse when committed by a man who should be held to a higher standard.

Are you all hypocrites? This pastor abused his athority and causes a great deal of pain. Defend him if you will, but you are reacting becuase of your friendship not the facts.
You cite critical thinking as a good thing, but then the bit about atheists being "created" by sexual abuse. Aren't atheists created by critical thinking and is that a bad thing? AND, here's another thing: Do you think a larger number of gay men go into the ministry (compared with other professions), throwing themselves full force into religion because it might "cure" homosexuality? Just wondering if this thought has occurred to others.
There are many paths to atheism. Critical thinking skills are a logical next step to a person moving away from superstition.

I have no idea on your second point. I've certianly never hear that theory expressed any credibility attached to it.
Not hypocritical, Joey...just delusional and brainwashed like millions of others. So very sad.
Hi Gang,
Is there any difference in this situation to the molester who first offers his victims an all-day sucker?
For example, an alderman was charged with dipping his fingers into the city's finances to the tune of $120,000 a year. When it came to charging him with a crime, there was an outcry from some of his constituents that he was a great guy because he contributed $20,000 a year to their community sports program. SEED MONEY!!!!
It would appear that our history is filled with tales of "religious leaders who lead their followers to Christ" and then rape them physically and literally. Those who would defend these "violators" are practicing cognitive dissonance and would be better off admitting their good fortune that they weren't one of the victims.
Mojoey said: "This is how atheists are born."

Mmm..nah. IThats a misleading and inaccurate assessment of what causes someone to accept reality over blind superstition. In fact, I'll take you to task and suggest that you are promulgating a misconception with that statement. I know alot of atheists...not one was as a result of clergy abuse.

Take the fundie nut case who is the first commenter above. He likely has been sexually abused by any number of god fearing, born again, hand waving, tounge talking, snake handling, holier than thou men of the cloth. But I doubt he/she would consider leaving the "group think" and blind idiocy of his bretheren. If he/she did, it would leave him on his own, without group support, having to deal with the real world with no hope of his/her useless life being made better after death.

Nah.... he/she could be butt phucked by every youth minister in the country...and he'd take it as long as that person brought him/her to "Chrust"."
1 reply · active 868 weeks ago
dromedaryhump - he's a little bit of my history for you. I only know about 10 atheist in person these days. Five of those became atheists via clergy induced sexual abuse. I've known these people for a very long time. Their stories are horrific. Their experiences were the spark needed for them to walk away from god and embrace rational thought. I should add... in most cases. One of my atheist friends believes in little green men. I drives me crazy, but what can you do?

Unfortunately, my reality is your politically unacceptable athesit myth. I know there are atheist out there who think about this like you do. I chose my words carefully, hoping to hook a big fish.

The funny thing is... I don't actually remember becoming an atheist. But my reasons for doing so have more to do with coming to understand that pastors can be power hungry abuse jerks. So even though I was not one of my seven friends abused by my church's choir director way back in the 70s, the abuse I suffered and the shitty relationships that resulted, sparked my doubt, which lead to my atheism.

And speaking of my seven abused friends, two killed themselves, two are in prison, and one is an angry atheist. I've lost track of the others.
Mojoey...
I don't mean to get all pedantic on you, but irrespective of your personal knowledge of these incidents, the VAST majority of the millions and millions of world wide atheists had zero sexual contact with clergy.

For you to make a definitive statement that this is what causes people to become atheists, even based on your rather unique experience , just diminishes/ devalues the logic, reason, intellectual honesty, acceptence of reality that drives the vast majority to become Free Thinkers.
Besides, attributing becoming atheist simply based on being molested by clergy, and for no other reason, begs this question: IF AN ATHEIST WERE MOLESTED BY A MENTOR ATHEIST, WOULD HE LIKELY BECOME THEIST?

If the answer is NO, then there is no foundational basis for what reads like an absolutist statement.
Finally: I am not suggesting that those who are molested by clergy don't have their faith shaken. But I am saying that :

a) if their belief in a supreme being were really that strong to begin with, and they didn't already have doubts founded in logic and reality, then the inappropriate act of another human would not in and of itself cause supernaturalism to be abandoned. It;s counter intuitive.

b) such incidents are comparitively miniscule and shouldnt be distorted to infer they are the cause of atheisim for the majority of atheists.

anyhow...
Oh man...double finally!! :)

How many times have you heard Christians dismiss atheism as not a product of intellect and thoughtful examination but simply due to some life crisis? Tell me you never heard them say:
"Why are you so angry at God? If a Christian hurt you at some time I'm sorry."

Thats the mythic and inane theist thought process that your statement, attributing atheism to clergy molestation promulgates. It does us all great injustice.

OK..now i'm done. sorry.
1 reply · active 868 weeks ago
You have a good point here. The fallacy (as I see it) is that your position is political. You are saying it is bad for the cause to acknowledge people lose their faith due to trauma. It happens.

I have an answer. I tell people I am not angry at god, I am angry at organized religion for putting me through hell. There was nothing divine in my experience. It was perpetrated by men.

I am capable of defending myself against any theist. It's my fellow atheists I have a problem with.
continued:

AND this assumes that EVERY VICTIM loses their FAITH as a result! That GOD ceases to be real to ALL of them because of the abuse of one man. Mojoey..at face this is impossible.

I think my question about if you were molested by an atheist mentor, would that cause you to become a theist is worth further consideration.

Heres a thought...take a poll. But I'd proffer itwould have to be outside this forum for it to be valid.

BTW, its not whther to can fend off the Xtian fallacy statements, its that by feeding the misconception as to where atheism derives whther you are doing an injustice to the integrity of atheist thought.

Anywho...I doubt I'll convince you...so I'll let it go now.

Thanks for the convo.
Hump
i dint say sexual abuse can't be a catlyst for someone breaking free from theism. It certainly can, and is. I'm only saying that for you to peg that as "how atheists are born" as THE primary cause for atheism (and thats how I am interpreting your comments) is, well, misguided, false, and statistically unsupportable.

If the population of the US is 10% atheist, your premise is that those 20 million (adult only) atheists are largely due t, either directly or tangently, to clergy sexual abuse.

There are 27k catholic priests in the US. , roughly 80k protestant ministers. That means that if every priest and miniister were a molester each of them would have had to molest 187 people, or some slightly lesser to account for "heresay" non experiential , collateral convertions.

If we assume 10% of clergy are molesters...then that number climbs to almost 1,900 victims per clergy pervert / or some slightly lesser number for the non-experiential / collateral loss of faith..
YIKES...READ THE BOTTOM ONE FIRST..AND THE TOP ONE SECOND :(
heheh!! I'm here to serve. ;)
This type of garbage is the reason no body will ever give Josh a fair chance ever again! This man litterally saved my life and never once did I ever feel like his kindness towards me was being fueled by his sexual desire for children! That to me is just insane! Nobody knows the whole story and until you do shut the hell up and stop crucifing a very good man who, yes, made a reprehensible and horrible mistake. To us a relationship with someone so young is unthinkable but in all honesty 16 yr olds today are more sexually and mentally mature than they were 10 yrs ago. Adults use sex to sell everything you see on tv, hear on the radio, ect and please tell me who spends the most time watching tv and listening to music? KIDS! And society expects them to understand that even though everything they hear or see is telling them sex is awesome it never hurts anyone, they arent seeing the consequenes of their actions! I blame the PARENTS! Yes I blame all you lazy worthless egg and sperm donors who never should have been parents in the first place! Who cares if your kids like you! Did you like your parents? Nope didn't think so! Set rules, enforce punishments and by punishments I dont mean these bullshit time outs that everyone is so fond of , no I mean spank your children not excessively of course but get ur point accross! Anyway you ugly soul less judgemental ginger bastard I hope you burn in the hell u so adamently dont believe in and get raped by demons daily! By the way its pretty pathetic that a grown man has nothing better to do than surf the internet for headlines to further your ignorant agenda without having a single clue as to what on GOD'S green earth you are talking about!

Post a new comment

Comments by