Monday, May 30, 2011

More thoughts on the homeless in San Jose

A noticed a homeless man while on a photowalk in downtown San Jose. It was odd because no one else did. He moved around the crowd like a ghost. He shambled from among the trashcans with his eyes downcast but alert. His hands snaked out to pick a half-eaten morsel. He did it again and again. The move was practiced and fluid. He his hand moved down, grabbed the food, and then slid it into his pocket.  While I watched he snagged enough food for a meal. Nobody noticed.

He did not eat any of this take. Instead, he walked away towards Cesar Chavez Park. I watched him for ten minutes. As I was about to leave I noticed another shambling trash-can-picker. He was every bit good as the first ghost. He even snagged a coffee that was left unattended on a table. I watched him closely. He did not make eye contact. No one noticed him. When he finished, he walked across to Cesar Chavez Park and sat on the same bench as the first ghost. I wondered if this were a coincidence.

I took a position in the park to shoot the cosplayers who were in San Jose for a convention. I keep my eye on the second ghost while shooting candid shots. Nobody paid any attention to him except that people kept their distance. It was as if he did not exist and was unclean.

Fifteen minutes passed. I saw the second ghost get up and start shambling away. I looked towards the food court and was not surprised to see another homeless man finishing his run through the food court. The second ghost had watched the new guys back. The new guy sat on the same bench and waited. He watched the food court as if his life depended on it. Nobody paid him any attention.  He did not exist.

I have a theory. I think these homeless guys were a crew building up enough food for a group meal. They watch for security or for the cops. They watch the crowds. They watch as leftover food goes into the trash. I think it is watching and the picking that keeps them alive. I'm not sure how to help.

Comments (10)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
In the wild you have Predators, Prey, and Scavengers. People are in effect not much different. You will always have those in society that for whatever reason live on the margins. You can help them with a single act of kindness ,or turn a blind eye to them. It would seem they have found a survival technique designed around a group/tribe co-operation . This was know doubt how human civilization began. I feel for them,and in the past have offered help,but just as with wild creatures they sometimes bite the hand that feeds them. I have found that giving to charities that help these people is a more effective course of action. You may not get the personnel gratification of helping just one person,but knowing your donations helped many is a good feeling also.
The simplest thing would to give the guy a sandwich.
3 replies · active 724 weeks ago
Andrew - I buy food for the homeless when I can. I always try to help. The deeper question has me perplexed, how do you solved the pervasive and persistent hunger in the homeless community? A sandwich feeds a man, I want to feed them all.
Well, I'm of two minds on this.
First, as a professional do-gooder (I work with folks who are disabled and the wife is a therapist) I do what good I can knowing that there will always be a need for more.
Second, it's always helpful to explore ways to get more bang out of your buck in terms of assisting folks (ie how can my limited resources be optimized?).

It sounds to me like you may be interested in getting involved with the public policy aspect of this problem.
I think you are right. I do my part, but I want to help fix the bigger problem.
Give him a sandwich by all means Andy. But if you had taken the time to read the post he was not just gathering food for himself. Paying $5 for a sandwich at the mall could go a lot further and feed more people if given to a food bank or soup kitchen .Or are you going to stop by every day ,and buy him and each one of his tribe a club Sandwich ? Subway $5 Five dollar foot longgggg !
If every person in America gave only $ 2.00 a week to feed the the needy that's $700,000,000 dollars a week ! We can wipe out hunger as a nation of 350,000,000 people. For less than the price of a cup of Star Bucks coffee each. As people who care let's make it happen ! No one in America should ever go hungry ! Some of us have more to give . Mojoey if you are serious ? I pledge $20 dollars a month to your Non-prophet cause. With your pull in the Atheist Community let's see what can be done .I'm serious maybe this can go beyond Ideology,and religion. And make this a better world for all Americans .
I'm homeless in San Jose (with my laptop, at the library) and found this post while searching for other homeless people to give them advice on what I've learned out here so far. Anyways, the problem is beds, not food. These guys you're referring to are purposely doing this. They do have a choice because food for the homeless is plentiful in this city. There's about 3 main shelters that feed people and I'm eating better than I ever did when I had my own place and 2 cars a few years ago. There's always seconds if people eat and are still hungry. So food is not a problem and these guys are either dumb or are too proud to walk into a shelter and eat there. Beds are the problem, because they are first come first serve at most places, and most of them charge after you've stayed there for about a week (30 days at some places, but the place I stay at charges after 1 week). So even people who have the money to get a bed aren't always guaranteed one, and are forced to sleep downtown or in parks where the cops continually harass them or arrest them for vagrancy or trespassing.
i am of the homless youth of san jose, and i dont agree that beds are the issue,not completley , i have a backack adn two blankets and ive kept warm, as long as i find a good stop were i can sleep thru the night. the issure for me is finding the place to sleep without getting woken up by the police and getting ticketed for tresspassing on public property or somthing out of the sort..
I have a much better suggestion. Many homeless people including myself (I still have shelter but not for long) would gladly donate their organs in return for a peaceful exit from this reality.

As this is not available, people like me resort to the only available means to exit (firearms). I do not want to be out in the street without shelter, so when the time comes, I have to find the courage to end my life or otherwise the suffering will intensify without shelter. I cannot find a job and am over 50. I am well-qualified and very experienced in software development. I am not mentally ill, do not take illegal substances and do not drink alcohol. But I cannot live on the street and I will not set foot in a homeless shelter - they are run by religious dimwits, they are dirty and full of mentally ill people. It's a one size fits all model where shelters are concerned.

Post a new comment

Comments by